Introduced by Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), Aaron's Law would amend the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) and wire fraud statute. In 2010, Swartz was charged with 13 felony wire fraud and hacking charges based on these laws. If Swartz had been convicted, he may have been forced to pay a large fine or have received a prison sentence of up to 35 years.
On January 16th, Rep. Lofgren publicly explained on Reddit that the charges against Swartz were due, in large part, to the sweeping and generalized language of the CFAA and wire fraud statute. According to Rep. Lofgren, the CFAA, if taken out of context or unclarified, could criminalize a number of "everyday" activities, allowing for severely enforceable penalties.
Rep. Lofgren is not alone in her stance against the bill's murky nature. According to the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), the CFAA's lack of specificity and clarity has allowed prosecutors bring criminal charges that target behavior that extends beyond hacking. An example is the United States v. Drew, where a woman created a fake MySpace page to harass a teenage girl who then committed suicide. In this case, the bullying was not illegal, so Drew was charged with violating the CFAA. Amending the CFAA would eliminate misuse of the bill's general language.
Lofgren maintains, especially in the wake of Swartz's death, that the CFAA and wire fraud statutes should be changed to exclude terms of service violations. This would correct potentially dangerous interpretations of the CFAA. Rep. Lofgren is currently seeking bill cosponsors.
Rep. Lofgren is not alone in her stance against the bill's murky nature. According to the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), the CFAA's lack of specificity and clarity has allowed prosecutors bring criminal charges that target behavior that extends beyond hacking. An example is the United States v. Drew, where a woman created a fake MySpace page to harass a teenage girl who then committed suicide. In this case, the bullying was not illegal, so Drew was charged with violating the CFAA. Amending the CFAA would eliminate misuse of the bill's general language.
Lofgren maintains, especially in the wake of Swartz's death, that the CFAA and wire fraud statutes should be changed to exclude terms of service violations. This would correct potentially dangerous interpretations of the CFAA. Rep. Lofgren is currently seeking bill cosponsors.
0 Comments